AIMS scores improving, but still below state averages

By Larry Blskey
Douglas Dispatch
Published/Last Modified on Wednesday, July 29, 2009 11:57 AM MDT


Overall, the Douglas Unified School District leaders were pleased with the state AIMS test, but there were still select areas, especially in math, that is causing come concern.


The AIMS test is given each spring and students wishing to graduate from high school are required to pass the test.

The district also received labeling from both the state and federal education departments based on AIMS and other areas.

“We had four underperforming  schools last year, this year only two,” said School District Superintendent Earl Pettit.

There were also two schools that did not make the “Average Yearly Progress (AYP)” label placed on them by the federal government,

Joe Carlson Elementary School and Ray Borane Middle School were still listed as underperforming after final tabulations of the last AIMS testing score.

Borane has been listed as “underperforming” by the state the last three years, and Carlson four out of the last five years.

Last year they were joined by Sarah Marley and Clawson elementary schools. The year, Clawson was given a label of “Performing” while Sarah Marley jumped all the way to “Performing Plus.”

Curriculum Director Leann Marston said “Everything we did this past year was an effort to put us in position to do well.”

“Even though two of the schools were still listed as under performing, we saw gains. Ray Borane students’ scores had significant gains this year.

“I am most proud of the job staff did at Sarah Marley. They were under performing and did not meet AYP last year. Now they are Performing Plus and are meeting AYP,” Marston said.

“One of the primary reasons for the AYP problems at Carlson and Borane schools is apparent once you look at the breakdowns. The English Language Learner program put in place by the state this past year had a negative impact on scoring even though it has done well in the school.

Students that are unable to pass an English Proficiency class are placed in a class which spend four hours a day, through the curriculum, reinforcing English, reading, writing, and speaking skills.

Marston said that while the program does a good job reinforcing and teaching English skills, it is not necessarily focused on AIMS standards, so those students in the programs may have trouble with the test.

The biggest overall improvement this year came in writing at Borane Middle School.  In 2008, only 47 percent of the students taking the test either met or exceeded the AIMS standards. This year that number jumped to 70 percent.

Marston credits a new writing program in the school with assisting in getting the improved grades.

“Math is still troublesome. We have hired match coaches for each of the middle schools and one coach to be split among the elementary schools.”

It is Marston’s hope that the district may be able to hire enough math coaches to have one at each school.

“The district has implemented a new math program over the last year, and some of the schools having problems haven’t used the new curriculum. The new program is much more closely aligned with the state standards. There is more hands-on learning with the new program,” Pettit said

While some may not completely understand or be in favor of the state’s AIMS testing program, Pettit said that the positive effect could easily be seen. “Academic achievement is up, Attendance is up, and graduation rate is up.

“I am proud of the district students and teachers and the job they did this year. We now need to keep moving in that direction.”

Third, fourth and fifth grade students in the elementary schools took the test. All three grades – sixth, seventh and eighth grades took the test in middle school while in high school they begin taking the test in 10th grade and continue taking it until they pass.

Following is a summary of the performance of each of the schools in the AIMS test and federal labeling:

Faras Elementary – Made AYP and Performing

In writing, Faras did well, increasing to 66 percent of the students who met or exceeded the standards – a 20 percent jump— in third grade while maintaining fourth and fifth grade levels.

In reading, Faras students had mixed scores, again increasing 20 percent in third grade, but dropping 10 percent in fourth grade.

In Math, fourth grade again dropped by a large margin – 16 percent.

Overall they are at or near Douglas Unified School District and state scores, except for writing, where the number of students meeting or exceeding standards is significantly lower than the state.

Joe Carlson Elementary School – Made AYP and underperforming

In writing, the number of students meeting or exceeding standards dipped by 16 percent, while fourth and fifth grade increased slightly.

In reading, students were at about the same levels as the previous year.

In Math, fourth grade students meeting or exceeding standards dipped by 9 percent, while fifth grade jumped by 11 percent.

Overall, Third grader are meeting standards at or about DUSD and state standards, but fourth and fifth grades are below those averages, and in some cases significantly below. In reading, the same trend continues, with third graders doing well, but fourth and fifth grades dropping. In Math, the number of students meeting standards is significantly lower in fourth and fifth grades. On the average, the school has 20 percent fewer students meeting and exceeding the standards in math compared to the rest of the state.

Clawson Elementary – Did not make AYP and Performing

In reading, third through fifth grade students did well, with an average of a 10 percent gain in the number of students meeting or exceeding standards.

In writing, the scores reflected the same trend. In Math, fourth graders showed a dip in standards but fifth graders did 10 percent better than their predecessors.

Overall, while there were big increases, fourth and fifth graders in reading and writing performed well below their state counterparts, while in math third and fourth graders performed under the state average, but fifth graders performed only one percentage point below the state average.

Stevenson Elementary – Made AYP and Performing Plus

In writing, Stevenson students in fourth and fifth grade saw slight increases, while third grade had a slight dip in the number of students meeting or exceeding state standards.

In reading, students were at or near the same levels they tested out at last year,

But in math, students did much more poorly than the previous year, dropping by an average of more than 10 percent in third and fourth grades.

Overall, students meeting or exceeding state standards were at or near state levels in writing and math, but slightly under in third and fourth grade reading.

Sarah Marley Elementary - Made AYP – Performing Plus

In writing, reading and math, third graders taking the test did much more poorly than they did the previous year. In each case 16 percent fewer students either met or exceeded the state standards.

Fourth graders did much better, increasing their passing rate by 28 percent in writing, 18 percent in reading and 7 percent in math.

In fifth grade they did just as well as last year in writing, but saw jumps of 29 and 28 percent in reading, and math, respectively.

Third graders performed below DUSD and state averages in all three subject areas, while fourth and fifth grades exceeded DUSD and state averages in writing, and met or exceeded DUSD levels in reading and math, but were slightly below state averages.

Huber Middle School -AYP and Performing.

In writing, Huber Middle School students did well in all three grades, increasing the percentage that met or exceeded standards. In sixth and seventh grades, students passed at a rate 20 percent higher than last year.

In reading, seventh graders did well, but sixth and eighth graders were at or near the same levels as last year.

In math, students performed at or about the same levels as last year.

Overall, Students exceeded the DUSD levels, but are still lagging behind the state average in writing. The same can be said for the reading testing as well as math. Huber students meeting or exceeding state standards are lagging about 10 percent behind state averages.

Borane Middle School- Did not make AYP and Under Performing

There were significant gains in sixth and seventh graders taking the writing test. A total of 37 and 38 percent more sixth and seventh grade students passed the AIMS test compared to last year. Eighth grade students were slightly ahead of last year’s levels.

While the students in seventh grade did well in the reading portion, sixth and eighth grades students saw a drop.

In Math, the same trend continued with seventh graders scores jumping up, but drops in sixth and eighth.

Overall, Sixth and seventh grade students taking the writing test were at or near DUSD levels, but were still significantly lower than the state average. It was even more pronounced in reading. In some cases the number of students meeting or exceeding state standards were at half or less of the state average.

The same occurred in sixth and eighth grade math.

Douglas High School – Made AYP and Performing Plus

Tenth grade scores are only reported for high school.

In writing and reading, the number of students meeting or exceeding state standards were at approximately the same levels, while in math, the high school had a 7 percent increase.

Overall, district high school students are at or near state averages in all three subjects.

 

 

Comments

    Guitar Picker wrote on Aug 12, 2009 1:02 PM:

    " Teachers have had to teach to the test for several years now in order to keep their school from looking bad on AYP and performance. I wonder how our students have been doing after graduation. Do they do well at Cochise College and the Universities their freshman year? When they get a job, do they know how to solve math problems and do they read, write and spell correctly? Or is the AIMS test keeping them from getting a well rounded education? Is it all about making sure the school looks good? "

    To teacher wrote wrote on Aug 5, 2009 9:35 PM:

    " So if there are 2 failing why would the schools think that they were just underperforming? Huh that is weird. Or is this another screw-up of Mr. B? "

    Hard Work wrote on Aug 2, 2009 10:12 PM:

    " As a member of the faculty at DHS I can tell you our administration is relentless in making sure our students are prepared to take AIMS seriously and do their best. Too bad Mr. Blaskey lumped all the schools together as performing below state averages. That is not the case. Douglas High School Performing Plus second year in a row,not an easy task given the challenges as compared to wealthy schools yet we're holding our own and no doubt will continue to grow! Way to go Bulldogs!! "

    DHS Pride wrote on Aug 2, 2009 10:07 PM:

    " Great job DHS students, teachers and administration! Although the paper didn't give you the credit you deserve, we the parents know how hard everyone there works to provide our kids with a good education. You have stayed focused and continue to make us proud! "

    Thanks wrote on Aug 1, 2009 9:39 AM:

    " Mr. Blasky thanks to your headlines and idiotic reporting it is no wonder it is difficult to to get people to move here much less teach in our schools. Don't you understand you could do much to help this community by the type of press you write. It's proably a good thing the Dispatch comes out once a week so we aren't subjected to your doomsday writing all week. You have been a big part of the problems in this ommunity with your reporting.There's a difference between the truth and slanting the truth to fit your perspective. Thanks but no thanks! "

    Credit wrote on Aug 1, 2009 9:31 AM:

    " It's hard to understand why the article has a focus on the least performing schools and does not give credit to the schools that are doing a great job. Ray Borane is underperforming no matter how you try to sugar coat it. Pay attention to the Performing Plus schools who have done their job well. Also Blasky has a way of making sure no one can feel the least validated by his stupid headlines. Only Blasky can manage to minimize all the efforts by students and teachers and principals to bring their schools to compliance. Blasky should be writing the Obiturary columms he has enough negativty and sour grapes attitude to do so. "

    Teach wrote on Jul 31, 2009 12:23 PM:

    " Two of the schools are actually Failing to Meet Standards, due to repeated years as Underperforming-that's 1/3 of our schools and puts DUSD in the bottom five districts in the state.This is shameful-particularly the spin of excuses. Our kids deserve better! "

    Chuck wrote on Jul 29, 2009 12:54 PM:

    " Congratulations, not even the late micro-managing superintendent could do this, I guess she just had to leave before results could be seen. "

Write a Comment

Comment posters are responsible for the opinions they express and the accuracy of the information they provide. We urge comment writers to treat this as a public forum where manners matter. We encourage a collegial, non-insulting tone. All readers comments must be approved by our staff before posting to the Web site. They review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Be aware, in accordance with the Communications Decency Act and provisions upheld in judicial appeal, that you are responsible for comments posted on this Web site. The Douglas Dispatch is not liable for messages from third parties.

DO NOT POST:
* Potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.
* Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
* Personal attacks, insults or threats.
* The use of another person's real name to disguise your identity.
* Comments unrelated to the story.
* Personal Information (phone numbers, addresses, etc.)

Opinions, advice and all other information expressed in douglasdispatch.com's reader comments represent the individual's own views and not necessarily those of the Douglas Dispatch. The Douglas Dispatch does not endorse and is not responsible for statements, advice or opinions offered by anyone other than authorized Douglas Dispatch spokespersons.

Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
   









Contact Us

Email the Editor
530 11th Street (85607)
P.O. Drawer H
Douglas, AZ 85608
tel: 520.364.3424
fax: 520.364.6750